This is a reflection that had been going on in the back of
my mind for years and I am a bit reluctant to share my concerns. But I think it’s
time for me to write something. I recognize that I am writing from the perspective
of a non-Honduran, seventy-year old celibate who is still very culturally from
the US. But I will dare to share my thoughts, hoping that others can help me
think through these concerns.
As I visit the communities throughout the parish, I have
found myself by the small number of people married in the church. I also am
surprised that there are so many who are not married civilly, even though they’ve
lived together for several years and have children. In face of this I keep
encouraging people to get married in the church.
But it’s not all that simple.
First of all, I wonder if there really is a culture of
marriage and the sacrament of matrimony in the villages. How many young people grow
up with single parents or with parents who are not married either civilly or in
the church?
There are also the costs of getting married civilly. You have
to get married civilly before you can get married in the church. The costs
could run to the equivalent of one hundred dollars.
There are also the expectations among some that a church wedding
has to be a big affair – and therefore costly.
There are also concerns about commitments and whether they’ll
be able to live up to them (and if the man will be faithful). The ideal of marriage
is set very high and there does not seem to be a realistic sense of the ways
that couples and families can really deal with conflict, complaints and so
forth. The presence of significant domestic violence bears witness to this.
Seeing couples breaking up can be another disincentive.
What I do see happening all too often is two people just getting
together. At times, there is a child on the way, but not always.
Recently, according to
an article I read, the Honduran
Congress just raised the marriage age to eighteen and abolished the possibility of
young people getting married if they were sixteen and had their parent’s
permission.
Belinda Portillo from children's charity Plan
International said Honduras had “made history” by passing the law in a country
where one in four children are married before the age of 18. “The fight against
child marriage is a strategic way of promoting the rights and empowerment of
women in various areas, such as health, education, work, freedom from violence…”
I don’t think this is good.
Am I wrong or jaded?
The problem is not that, until now, the law permitted
marriage under eighteen with parental consent. though the person had to be sixteen.
A new law will not stop young people cohabiting before they
are eighteen. They just won't be able to be legally married.
What is the problem? Why do I see so few couples married?
As I see it, there is not a culture of marriage in many places. A macho culture
may also be responsible for part of this. Lack of decent formation in sexuality
is lacking.
In addition, n many places, there is nothing to do after sixth
grade. Jobs, outside of work on the farm or seasonal work on the coffee
harvest, are hard to find.
Even if there is a law that mandates education till ninth
grade, how many kids drop out of school even before finishing sixth grade. The
other day in one village, talking with kids, three ten-year olds told me that
they had dropped out of school in the second or third grade. The common
complaint was boredom.
There are classes up to sixth grade in almost every village,
at least around here. But in one zone of the parish there is only one place where
“educación básica” – the equivalent of middle school – is offered during the week.
There is one weekend program. But there are villages where there is no “middle school”
within thirty minutes walking distance and there is very limited public
transportation. Yes, there are families who value education and see that their
children get middle school and even high school education. But these young
people often have to go to Santa Rosa – more than an hour away with a
significant bus fare.
To be truthful, there are families that do not value education,
especially for girls. They want the young people to help the family by working in
the fields or in the house.
There are other families that make major efforts for the education of their children or grandchildren.
I am a strong advocate of education for young people, but I
realize the problems here.
I also am an advocate of marriage. But the challenge is the
lack of preparation for adolescence and adulthood among the young people. And sexual
education? I once asked a few of the youth group leaders about this. In the schools,
it’s about avoiding diseases (and pregnancy). Catechists and religious leaders
in the communities seldom speak about sexuality – and most often it’s in terms of
what not to do. But there seems to be almost no formation in emotional
development.
What do I do? I encourage people living together with
children to get married. I see a good number of them who come to the Masses or Celebrations of the Word and, of course, don't receive communion.
I also encourage young men I know who are in
relationships to respect the young women and, with those whom I think trust me,
I even advise them, mischievously, “Keep your zipper zipped up.”
But more needs to be done, especially among the young. We
need to find ways to promote healthy relationships among the young before and
during marriage.
A law prohibiting marriage of 17 year olds even with
parental permission looks good – but I fear this will not help. I think it may only discourage marriages.
What do you think?